It truly has been an interesting week for those are concerned about peak oil and climate change here in Australia.
Early in the week the senate actually had a motion moved to acknowledge and look seriously at the peak oil issue in relation to Australia. Unsurprisingly the motion was defeated 31:6.
The thing is this isn't all bad news. Sure it would be better if our senate had passed the motion but really the breakthrough is the motion was raised in the first place. The Greens senator involved was obviously convinced they were not going to get embarrassed by being the only person to support this motion. Not only was it raised but 16% of the voting senators supported the motion.
To me though, the important bit is that the issue has been raised. It has been made public and the Australian senate now has a vote on record about this issue. Even though all major party senators simply voted along party lines if just a few senators get interested enough in what they were voting about to do a bit of research that gap might slowly close. Most importantly it forever makes any future claim of ignorance impossible. The issue has been put before the senate and voted upon so while I don't celebrate the result I do think it is a step in the right direction.
The second and more contentious issue currently under discussion is the Emissions Trading Scheme. Honestly the bill that was put forward in August only considered the science in a 'passing wave' fashion. Even at that point it was never going to be enough but at least it could almost be said to be a partially credible starting point. The work that has been put into watering it down since it was defeated to make it passable has been a real education in "political reality".
It seems political reality has absolutely no basis in actually achieving anything useful. In fact its only link to reality seems to be that it has to convince people that you are doing something even if it isn't an effective response.
I have to say that this piece of legislation has me quite conflicted. I truly believe that Australia needs legislation in place. The problem for me is that this legislation basically guarantees that we won't act in a globally responsible manner for a very long time. I could probably live with it if it was going to be reviewed in 12 months. In my view for the timeline this legislation currently covers it ensures that big polluters will be able to afford to stay that way for far too long.
This world, it's a complex place. Regardless of what is happening at the national level I will continue to try to raise awareness and build support. The main political reality is that politicians are reactionary. Without most people in Australia telling their politicians that they believe the future of their children is more important that cheap products or food the moves will be few and far between. I can't change legislation but I can, in my local community, advocate for change. I can build the awareness needed to ensure that the politicians are forced to stand up and be counted on these issues.
I have power, so do you.....
Made by Me - Jo Sharp Reversible Wrap
11 minutes ago
4 comments:
nice post. thanks I never can get bothered enough to write a thinking piece on my blog..time n brain n all. I agree with you. Im conflicted but i think some step is nbetter than none in this case. The people are ready, the pollies arent! and God knows whats going on in the Liberal party . Malcolm certainly chose the wrong party when he had the choice! Dragging that bunch of luddite along cant be fun.
Hi Kelly,
I certainly agree that a step forward is better than none... the time line it locks us in to is the main thing that concerns me.
I have to disagree with you that the people are ready. One of the reasons politicians won't act is because what the population is actually saying. All the surveys and polling I have seen on this basically say what we are communicating is "fix this problem but make sure it doesn't cost anything".
Needless to say that really ain't gunna happen so politicians have decided that we really don't want effective action.
Kind Regards
Belinda
great blog!I want to blog about this but also can't think too coherently at the moment! But it fills me with amazement to hear right wing idiots denying the existence of climate change. How far in denial are they?! I think the majority of the people I know support an ETS, but then I move in fairly left wing circles so I guess they would. *sigh*
Thanks Spiralmumma,
I have been forever convinced that the only thing that is going to convince the right wing of climate change is the ocean lapping at the doorstep of their sea side mansions. I wake up every day wanting to be proven wrong but to this point I can't say my opinion has changed.
I have the same problem as I have a large amount of enviro/sustainability people around me. These types of political squabbles never fail to amaze me.
Kind Regards
Belinda
Post a Comment